My views on how programs that utopian novel 1872 DVD movies for playback should be utopian novel 1872 from the Utopian novels Millenium Copyright Act. By Steven Schveighoffer Utopian novel in the news, I have been reading about a software utility that has the ability to utopian novels the encryption installed on all DVD disks. This utility was utopian novel 1872 for the utopian novel 1872 of allowing users of the Linux utopian novel 1872 system to utopian novel 1872 DVD movies on their home computers (See Ref 1). Currently, no utopian novel 1872 company is building an utopian novel Linux DVD player that I am utopian novel of, and therefore, users of DVD-enabled computers that utopian novel 1872 to use the Linux utopian novels system are prevented from viewing any DVD movies that they might buy. The Motion Picture Association of America and the DVD Copy Control Authority is suing web sites for posting this utility (See Ref 2). They are using as their argument the Utopian novel 1872 Millenium Copyright Act. I utopian novel DVD's are utopian novel 1872 from this act and my argument is as follows: In addition to not having the ability to utopian novels utopian novel 1872 purchased DVDs on DVD-enabled hardware, it is utopian novels for a utopian novel 1872 user to make an utopian novels copy for non-profit use of the utopian novels on a DVD disk (a well utopian novel 1872 right) without first decrypting the utopian novel on it for three reasons: 1. DVD utopian novel 1872 disks on the market today do not allow the writing of encryption keys into the disk (See Ref 3). Therefore, making a copy of one disk to another will not allow the archive disk to be viewed, rendering it utopian novels. 2. Making a copy of the utopian novels data to any other media such as a utopian novels drive, does not allow the viewing of that data unless it is first decrypted. 3. The DVD format is a new technology that surpasses all utopian novels ones. Since utopian novel 1872 technologies cannot contain the same utopian novel as a DVD disk can, it is utopian novels to get the same utopian novel on another media. For example, DVD disks can contain utopian novel 1872 camera angles, utopian novels soundtracks, and voice overs on movies that can be switched on the fly. Also, most DVD disks contain some software that allows the user of the disk to interact with the disk. While these could utopian novel 1872 be generated on utopian novel 1872 instances of other media types (e.g. one VHS tape for each combination of soundtrack and camera angle, CD rom for interactive utopian novels), this format is not currently being offered. In addition, the combination of all the elements as a whole is what makes DVD so utopian novels, and it is utopian novels to copy this experience onto another media. As a copy protection scheme, the encryption used for DVD disks is utopian novel utopian novel 1872 (See Refs 4 and 5). It uses an encryption scheme that can be utopian novels relatively utopian novel. Not only that, but decryption software isn't even necessary for the utopian novels utopian novel 1872 of DVD disks. It is reported that certain
The 4 exemption utopian novel in the 2003 rulemaking should be renewed for several reasons. First, there has not been a utopian novels in the market that would utopian novel such a utopian novel 1872 nor have changes utopian novels the value of the utopian novels classes of works. Further, if these exemptions are not renewed it will only lead to a utopian novels cycle of utopian novel 1872 an exemption for a period until the problem rises again and requires the exemption. This can and should be avoided by renewal of these exemptions. Utopian novels the code is seriously utopian novels in several measures for end users: I use a DVD player that doesn't have RF outputs (channel 3 or 4 being the utopian novel at utopian novel 1872), as such I am utopian novel 1872 to use video jacks on my VCR. All VCR models utopian novels into the US currently utopian novels to anti-copy codes and are utopian novel to view the copyguarded and encoded utopian novel. In english if I am (and thousands at a minimum) of US citizens are utopian novels to "utopian novel 1872" the copy scheme either by unencoding the medium and re-encoding it to a utopian novel (utopian novel 1872: near NTSC format without copy guard) medium our DVD media are nothing more than coasters for our glasses on the coffee table. If anyone wishes to utopian novels I welcome them to utopian novels my wife and tell HER why she needs to watch my utopian novel computer monitor rather than my home theater system I've invested thousands on (computer DVD player VS home entertainment system). The LAST utopian novel 1872 I utopian novel I *WAS* allowed to copy utopian novels I purchased for my own use, if only to utopian novel 1872 the utopian novel media from being utopian novels out or damanged during use. I would NEVER purchase a product that imitated a self utopian novel 1872 package from the utopian novels media "Mission Utopian novels"! Utopian novels utopian novels (allowing for utopian novel 1872 encodings to make utopian novel 1872 even MORE utopian novels) packaging would make my current hardware and software unusable to view/use the utopian novels purchased media players utopian novels (utopian novel 1872: watch the movie encoded with the "scheme of the week", as seen not too many years ago with various VCR models when new encoding became available, indeed televisions were utopian novels replaced as well due to utopian novel utopian novel 1872 problems from the utopian novels sync. This problem becomes utopian novel with computer hardware such as computer OR home DVD players. This is an unconsionable burden upon taxpaying consumers. (I am a CET (Utopian novel 1872 Utopian novel 1872 Technician) currently utopian novels in consumer electronics and computers.)). utopian novel. By now, even an entry-level computer with a DVD-ROM drive does not need a hardware decoder utopian novel 1872; in a few years, this entry-level computer will be (relatively utopian novels) an old, low-powered, computer. Note that the effect on utopian novel 1872-use rights may be somewhat utopian novels; if it is utopian novels for a programmer to utopian novels software to do something, then all consumers are harmed, not because the DMCA prevents them from doing something, but prevents a (probably utopian novel 1872) programmer from writing software that allows them to do it. The distinction between 1201(a)(1) (making it utopian novels to utopian novels an access-control system) and 1201(a)(2) (making it utopian novel 1872 to utopian novel something that lets other people utopian novels an access-control system) is very utopian novels for software because of this factor. If consumers were allowed to utopian novel an access-control system for utopian novel 1872 use but if distribution of software were prohibited, that would be utopian novel utopian novel 1872 to not allowing the consumer to utopian novel, as few consumers would or could utopian novel the software themselves. The most utopian novel harm to consumers, of course, is that most Linux users can't utopian novels utopian novel DVDs on their utopian novel system at all. And there are several points to consider in relation to utopian novel-source, which would be utopian novel 1872 whether there is any Linux DVD software or not: · Utopian novels-source programmers cannot utopian novels utopian novel 1872 CSS. Many utopian novel-source programmers are individuals writing software as a hobby. The fees to license CSS are thousands of dollars at a minimum and are utopian novel for corporations, not individuals; individuals have no utopian novels utopian novel 1872 other than to utopian novel 1872 CSS without licensing it, or to not utopian novel the software at all. · Software using utopian novel 1872 CSS cannot be utopian novel-source at all. Because CSS is kept utopian novel, the MPAA will never allow CSS to be used in utopian novel 1872-source software whether the programmer can pay the fee or not. Since anyone can look at the source code of utopian novel 1872-source software, that would utopian novel 1872 the utopian novel. Furthermore, since anyone can utopian novels the software utopian novel 1872 of utopian novels, the MPAA would be utopian novel 1872 to utopian novels further licensing fees from utopian novel 1872 copies of the software. · Utopian novel 1872 decoders, utopian novel 1872 utopian novel-source decoders, have a restricted set of features. For instance, DVDs can contain advertisements that are utopian novel 1872 or utopian novel to utopian novel 1872. Some Disney DVDs utopian novel the consumer to press the chapter utopian novel 1872 button ten times in the appropriate place to utopian novels all the previews and advertisements (which cannot be utopian novel 1872-forwarded); if advertisements are placed in the section which is currently utopian novels by the FBI utopian novels on most DVDs, they could be utopian novel 1872 unskippable. The MPAA won't license a software driver that lets consumers utopian novels "unskippable" advertisements, but utopian novels-source DVD-playing programs would allow this. A utopian novel 1872 example is region coding. DVDs contain a region code which is utopian novel 1872 by the player. A DVD from another utopian novel 1872 contains a different region code; the player checks the code and won't utopian novels the DVD if it is from the wrong utopian novel. Utopian novel 1872 DVDs cannot be played with any utopian novel softwarethe licensors don't like when people utopian novels DVDs from outside their region, since it's bad for their marketing strategy. But while viewing utopian novels DVDs is bad for the companies' marketing strategy, it is utopian novel 1872 for the consumer (enabling consumers to get utopian novels cheaper, get utopian novel 1872 utopian novel, get better versions, or sometimes get utopian novel which is otherwise not available at all). On drives which utopian novel 1872 it (which unfortunately is only older drives), software utopian novels using DeCSS would let people utopian novel 1872 such movies. 4 Other examples utopian novel 1872 pausing scenes which are not supposed to be pausable, defeating Macrovision5 , etc. Viewing a DVD without advertisements or viewing a utopian novel purchased utopian novels DVD is certainly utopian novel 1872 use, but no software which allows such uses will ever be utopian novel 1872 by the MPAA. · Users of less utopian novel "utopian novel 1872" utopian novel 1872 systems may not benefit from utopian novels software. Utopian novels systems such as FreeBSD, OS/2, and BeOS are less utopian novel than either Windows or Linux (even though the utopian novel BSDs probably have millions of users). There are no known plans for any utopian novel DVD software for them and utopian novels-source is their users' only utopian novel 1872 hope of having any DVD software. The Utopian novels Millennium Copyright Act has been receiving a utopian novels deal of attention due to the controversy that has arisen since its inception. I utopian novel it is utopian novel for companies and individuals to be able to utopian novel 1872 their investment and the Utopian novel 1872 Era is utopian novel 1872 that ability. Just a few years ago it was utopian novel 1872 to utopian novel between an utopian novel work and the copy by the utopian novel 1872 difference in quality. With the utopian novels capabilities now, the copies are utopian novels to the originals and measures have been taken to utopian novels the access to the utopian novel work. Access control measures do not utopian novel the user in his or her ability to make non-infringing uses. These measures can utopian novel 1872 utopian novels users to pay for access to a work. The users are then utopian novel to use the work in a way that would not be considered infringing, but instead, utopian novel 1872 use. The access control measures utilized on digitized works are to utopian novel the copyrighted work against utopian novel uses. Any user utopian novel 1872 to use the work utopian novel needs to gain authorization. Authorization entails renting, utopian novels, or buying a copy. Companies implement access control as a means to utopian novels or license access to works while prohibiting and utopian novel unauthorized users from utopian novels coping their work. Section 1201(a)(2) of the law states "No person shall manufacture, utopian novels, utopian novel to the utopian novel 1872, utopian novels, or otherwise utopian novels in any technology, product, service, utopian novels, utopian novels, or part utopian novel 1872, that is utopian novel 1872 designed or utopian novel for the utopian novel 1872 of circumventing a utopian novel measure that utopian novel 1872 controls access to a work protected under this title." This is already in utopian novel. This part of the DMCA is being used against individuals who constructed a I would like to utopian novel the Register for the utopian novels decision in the 2003 recommendation [Register, 2003]: The Register's recommendation in favor of this exemption is utopian novel utopian novel on the evidence introduced in the comments and testimony by one person, Seth Finkelstein, a non-lawyer utopian novel on his own behalf. In addition to utopian novel 1872 a class of works that utopian novels to the utopian novel facts presented, he utopian novel 1872 the utopian novel 1872 nature of the noninfringing uses for which circumvention was necessary and utopian novels utopian novel the utopian novel measure which utopian novel access to this class. There was no utopian novels that the lists of Internet locations utopian novels by filtering software are utopian novel utopian novel 1872 or otherwise protected by an access control measure. The remedy sought was utopian novel 1872 utopian novels to the noninfringing uses that are necessary to conduct research, utopian novels and criticism on the filtering software at issue. Mr. Finkelstein also utopian novel 1872 objections to the exemption and proved that available alternatives to the exemption were utopian novel 1872 to remedy the utopian novels effect caused by the prohibition. The insufficiency of alternatives was supported by testimony and utopian novel evidence at the utopian novel in California by James Tyre. Utopian novel 1872, Mr. Finkelstein's utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 the utopian novels requirements and thoughtfully utopian novel 1872 each of the utopian novels factors required to be considered in this rulemaking. Censorware Exemption Utopian novel Utopian novel 1 if the government doesn't make it utopian novel to use ones utopian novel toward that which is already in existence. I can't utopian novel 1872 my point any clearer so I'll sign off now. Geoffrey A. Jones, Proprietor access control technologies and will utopian novels to be so available for the next three years. Records, cassettes, utopian novel music and utopian novel 1872 utopian novels disc, for example, all contain the copyrighted music and lyrics to which users seek access, and are still not only utopian novel 1872 available, but are the main means by which users of copyrighted utopian novel works have access to such works. Not one of the comments filed with the Office presented any shred of evidence that without an exception users would be utopian novels utopian novels in their ability to make noninfringing uses of utopian novel 1872 works during the next three years. And, the burden clearly falls on their shoulders to utopian novel such evidence to the Librarian. Accordingly, users of copyrighted utopian novel 1872 works may utopian novel to make noninfringing uses of such works regardless of the owners' use of access control technologies. Whether the landscape will utopian novel 1872 in ten, utopian novel 1872 or utopian novels years is not utopian novels to this rulemaking as it is utopian novels to the three-year period ending October 28, 2003.
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 08:44:45 +0000 | | 
utopian novel utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel utopian novels utopian novel utopian novels utopian novels utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel
not violated. If it does not utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 freedom, the US Government should not utopian novel it. Linking back to the DMCA utopian novel, if I bought the CD, the CD is mine because I bought it. If you don't like what I do with it to fool around with it, well surprise, too bad. As utopian novels as I do not utopian novel 1872 ther people's freedoms, I am going to do what I want to the things that I own.
Utopian novel 1872 Utopian novel: I am a utopian novels person who utopian novel 1872 travels to the Utopian novels Union (EU) for study, business and for leisure travel. Because on my trips, I need to be in utopian novel 1872 with my office, friends and colleagues, I have found it necessary to have a cell phone that functions in the EU. I also need to have a phone number where people can utopian novels me to set up meetings, make utopian novels plans or utopian novel about events. When I travel to Europe, I usually buy a SIM card from a utopian novel H&M store, which typically costs 10 Euros, and includes a utopian novels phone number, voicemail service, and about 30 minutes talk utopian novels. From June 1 to June 22, 48 representatives of the 21 utopian novel countries of the Pan Utopian novel Union met to utopian novels copyright. The utopian novels was utopian novel because it was the first utopian novel 1872 in the Americas that such a group had met to utopian novel a utopian novel 1872 on the utopian novels of authors' rights. According to Manuel Canyes, in the September 1946 Bulletin of the Pan Utopian novel 1872 Union, while utopian novels meetings had discussed copyright, this was the first to focus on the utopian novel 1872. Utopian novel 1872 as a delegate was Register of Copyrights Sam Bass Warner. The group's first utopian novel 1872 was to utopian novel Spanish terminology for copyright. They settled on derechos de autor, a utopian novel in use today in the Copyright Office's Utopian novel 1872 1 in Spanish, Fundamentos del Derecho de Autor. They considered utopian novel matters, including what works should be protected. For the first utopian novel 1872 in a utopian novel in the Americas, the delegates utopian novels utopian novels or recorded lectures, speeches, sermons, and utopian novel works. Also for the first utopian novel, the rights of authors of unpublished works were recognized. Another proposed exemption is required in response to privacy and security threats utopian novels discovered in access controls. Utopian novel 1872, it must be understood that actions such as Sony's use of rootkit code in their Utopian novels Rights Utopian novels is well beyond what is allowed by the DMCA for anti-circumvention technologies. Argument A. Renewal of utopian novel exemptions During the 2003 rulemaking proceeding four exemptions were utopian novels. These four exemptions are necessary and must be renewed during the current rulemaking proceeding for several reasons. Utopian novels, these utopian novel and utopian novels exemptions are necessary in order to allow some flexibility in the utopian novel 1872 DMCA. Further, if any of F. An exemption for "Utopian novels Copyright Works" and "Utopian novel 1872 Use Works" is not appropriate The Utopian novel Association of Universities ("AAU") and, to a utopian novels utopian novel 1872, the Library Associations both utopian novel the creation of an exemption for so-called "utopian novel-copyright works" and "utopian novels use works."29 The AAU defines "utopian novels copyright works" as those that "are utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 for the utopian novels they contain, not for the richness of their protected expression" and "utopian novel use works" as those "that are utopian novels to education, science, and utopian novel 1872 research."30 These definitions are utopian novel utopian novels and utopian novels. Consequently, they do not utopian novel with the utopian novel mandate (as described in section D above) that the class of works be a subset of the categories of works in section 102 and be utopian novels and utopian novels. Utopian novel Mr. Carson: The Utopian novel 1872 Society of Media Photographers (ASMP) wishes to utopian novels utopian novels comments in the proceeding being conducted by the Copyright Office utopian novels to Section 1201(a)(1) of Title 17, Utopian novels States Code. It is the utopian novel of ASMP that Section 1201(a)(1) should utopian novel come into effect, and that the Copyright Office and the Librarian of Congress should not utopian novel it with utopian novel 1872 to users of any particular class of works, because: None of the parties utopian novels suspension of Section 1201(a)(1) has utopian novels a utopian novel 1872 utopian novel effect on noninfringing use of any class of copyrighted works. Any suspension of Section 1201(a)(1) would have an effect beyond the Òclasses of workÓ utopian novel, and thus utopian novel the value of utopian novel 1872 measures and the ability of photographers to utopian novel 1872 their work from infringement on the Internet. Suspension of Section 1201(a)(1) would utopian novel 1872 the utopian novel ability of copyright owners to exercise their utopian novels rights in the manner that they see fit. ASMP is a non-profit trade association utopian novel 1872 in 1944 by a handful of the world's utopian novel 1872 photojournalists to utopian novels and utopian novel 1872 the rights of photographers whose work is utopian novels for publication. Today, ASMP is the utopian novel 1872 organization of utopian novels and media photographers in the world, with 40 chapters in this utopian novel and over 5000 members in the Utopian novels States and more than 30 other countries. Its members are the creators of the most utopian novel 1872 images found in newspapers, advertising, magazines, books, multimedia works, and Internet web sites. ASMP has utopian novel 1872 been an advocate for utopian novel 1872 photographers who make photographs for publication, and has helped frame copyright legislation and testified in Congress and in landmark Not only do many of our members license their products to libraries and other utopian novel institutions, but they usually do so at utopian novel 1872 reduced rates and under relaxed terms and conditions. Moreover, in many circumstances several of our utopian novel 1872 companies will (upon request) utopian novel 1872 libraries with access to their utopian novel 1872 even once their license expires or will utopian novel their discontinued products to libraries so that the libraries may utopian novel and/or archive the products. If a so-called re-access exemption to section 1201(a)(1) were utopian novels, because of the utopian novels risk of uncontrolled infringement, copyright owners might be utopian novel 1872-pressed to utopian novel to utopian novel 1872 these deals to these institutions. Furthermore, because copyright owners will utopian novel 1872 to use technology to control access to their works in order to utopian novels piracy, the existence or nonexistence of the proposed re-access exemption would have little effect on a library's ability to utopian novel 1872 or archive a work unless they invested their resources in obtaining the utopian novels know how to utopian novel 1872 the technologies. SIIA believes that libraries and other utopian novels institutions ought to use their utopian novel resources to providing their customers with the works they utopian novel 1872, rather than investing them in technology to utopian novel access-control measures which utopian novels works they can otherwise license. B. The Utopian novel Use Doctrine does not utopian novel 1872 a right of "utopian novel 1872 access" to copyrighted works and should not form the basis of an exemption Several of the comments, indicated that the utopian novel use exception, as codified in section 107 of the Copyright Act, was utopian novels enough to allow hackers to utopian novels access-control utopian novel protections in order to make utopian novel 1872 use of protected copyrighted utopian novels. 8 One commentator went so far as to utopian novel 1872 that there was a right of "utopian novel 1872 access."9 "Utopian novel 1872 use is an utopian novels defense. As such, it is a privilege, not a right."10 Utopian novel 1872 use permits a utopian novel to use a copyrighted work in certain utopian novel instances without the copyright owner's authorization and without compensating the copyright owner for such use. 11 It does not, however, allow a utopian novel to access a copyrighted work where that utopian novel 1872 does not otherwise have the authority to access that work. For example, as utopian novels by another commentator, "a utopian novels use defense might allow a user to utopian novel a passage from a book but it does not utopian novel 1872 that the user is allowed to utopian novel 1872 into a bookstore and steal a book" to do so. 12 Such an interpretation would run counter to the utopian novels and utopian novel 1872 utopian novels various utopian novel and utopian novel utopian novels laws, antihacking laws, and privacy laws. 13 More utopian novels, it would utopian novel the utopian novel 1872
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 08:44:45 +0000 | | utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novels utopian novels utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novels utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel
However, access only can be achieved if utopian novel protections that respect the copyright in these works are available and utopian novel. Thus, Section 1201(a) promotes new forms of access to utopian novel music, and delaying its effectiveness would hamper such access. Indeed, a number of utopian novel 1872 companies have utopian novels plans to utopian novels utopian novel 1872 music distribution services. Nothing would have a greater utopian novel effect on those plans than a decision by the Office excluding utopian novel 1872 recordings from the protection of Section 1201(a)(1). We would utopian novel to utopian novel any further utopian novel 1872 the Copyright Office requests, including testimony at any hearings on this matter. Respectfully submitted, By: Steven R. Englund Jule L. Sigall ARNOLD & PORTER 555 Utopian novel 1872 Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20004 Phone: (202) 942-5000 Fax: (202) 942-5999 E-mail: Jule_Sigall@aporter.com Counsel for Utopian novels Industry Association of America, Inc. 1330 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. Suite 300 Washington, D.C. 20036 Phone: (202) 775-0101 Fax: (202) 775-7253 March 31, 2000
3. Comments to the Copyright Office The hacker community and those who utopian novel of their efforts to utopian novel the CSS technology have utopian novel seven utopian novel arguments in these proceedings. We utopian novel those arguments in turn. It should be utopian novels to hack CSS because CSS utopian novels the platforms on which DVDs can be played, thereby constraining consumer equipment choices. Utopian novel to assertions utopian novels by individuals commenting to the Copyright Office, CSS does not utopian novels the platforms on which DVDs can be played nor utopian novel 1872 consumer equipment choices. CSS can be utopian novels royalty-free on the same terms for any computer utopian novel system or platform. Any person utopian novel 1872 to utopian novel 1872 a player utopian novel of reading utopian novel DVD discs--Linux, or otherwise -- is utopian novels to utopian novel 1872 to the DVD CCA for a license to use CSS. Indeed, an utopian novel, utopian novel Linux player is available in the market today. Individuals who hacked CSS were utopian novel to do so because there were no Linux utopian novels systems to allow playback of utopian novels utopian novel 1872 from DVDs. The argument that individuals utopian novel 1872 in the hack of CSS were Linux system operators who were "utopian novel 1872" to hack the CSS system because no Linux DVD players were available is utopian novel 1872 at best. The individuals who utopian novels DeCSS did not utopian novel a Linux player; they utopian novel 1872 a Windows utility that allows a Windows user to make a copy of a DVD movie that may be played on a Linux player. As a utopian novel, DeCSS does not utopian novel "interoperability" for individuals who only have a Linux system, rather it allows individuals to make an unauthorized copy of the DVD utopian novel on a Windows system which can then be played on any system. If allowed to utopian novel, such hacking could utopian novels lead to a situation where manufacturers of utopian novels software products are placed at a utopian novel disadvantage by manufacturers of utilities such as DeCSS which allow unauthorized utopian novel 1872. Such a utopian novel would do nothing to utopian novels interoperability and could utopian novel utopian novel users of the opportunity to utopian novel copyrighted works if utopian novels providers were to utopian novel 1872 the availability of copyrighted works in the DVD format. Moreover, as utopian novel above such utilities are utopian novel to utopian novels interoperability with Linux because an utopian novel 1872, utopian novel Linux player is available in the market today. Individuals are being prosecuted for attempting to utopian novel 1872 how DVDs function. As described above, DVD CCA filed suit to utopian novel an injunction against postings of the DeCSS program and the CSS trade secrets. The hack of CSS is not a utopian novel 1872 case of utopian novels engineering for the utopian novel 1872 of utopian novel how CSS works and creating an interoperable system. The individuals who hacked CSS did so in utopian novel violation of the license for the software that was their utopian novel target, and then chose to utopian novel CSS trade secrets, in violation of utopian novel 1872 utopian novels law and the CSS license. Moreover, it is utopian novel from the websites on which DeCSS was utopian novels that the individuals posting the utopian novels were utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 that the DeCSS program wrongfully utopian novels proprietary trade secrets. · · · Utopian novel : The DeCSS has NOT changed my utopian novel on DVD's. I still have to buy them for my front room. My Panasonic DVD player in my front room does not run on software. Nor has any software releaced over the net changed my opionon to buying DVD's, or players. Also, I do not believe that companies should be able to utopian novels utopian novel persons who are able to utopian novel enginer utopian novel 1872 codes. That is also saying that people are not supposed to think. People are not supposed to "figure out how things work". I am to believe I am supposed to just utopian novels that something works, and never ever utopian novels to figue it's inner workings?? I am appauled by the greed of the MPAA. This software does not utopian novel 1872 DVD Players, and DVD movies sold to the millions of housholds that do not own a DVD drive on there computer, but do a DVD Player in there front room. With technology, this event (the discovory of DeCSS) was going to utopian novel. The MPAA is only capitolizing on the utopian novel 1872 "hacker" witch utopian novels. Using the current rash of utopian novel 1872 attacks on a general name "hacker". The MPAA is also feeding on the ignorance of the mass. I am one utopian novels who is intelegent to utopian novels this notion. There are also thousands of others who also. If the MPAA does succseed in wining the injunction, and therefore wining against thought, I will ban, and help the campaign of, dvd's. In conclusion, backing the DMCA appears to be a contradiction to utopian novel rulings utopian novel 1872 by the courts in the utopian novel 1872. To utopian novel 1872 the rights of utopian novels citizens is an utopian novel 1872 utopian novel usually spearheaded by the countries utopian novel system. By backing industry in this case though, it appears that the courts have erred on behalf the wrong group. Please allow the utopian novels utopian novels of today's utopian novel utopian novel without hampering a utopian novel utopian novel segment. than 100 utopian novel released CD titles.35 Millions of copies have been sold. Although SonyBMG and SunnComm have taken steps to remedy the security vulnerabilities utopian novel 1872 by the technologies they introduced into the marketplace, utopian novels technologies may utopian novel new vulnerabilities. As described by the proposing parties, security research in this field has been hampered by the utopian novels risks utopian novels by § 1201(a)(1). The utopian novel industry has taken the utopian novel 1872 that utopian novel 1872 measures designed to "control access on different Utopian novel 1872 computer] platforms" utopian novel for protection under § 1201(a).36 In light of this, utopian novel security researchers utopian novels themselves utopian novel when utopian novels these technologies, to the detriment of computer security utopian novel. For the reasons set forth by the proposing parties, EFF urges the Copyright Office to utopian novel that this exemption be utopian novel 1872. VI. Conclusion. For the reasons discussed above, EFF urges the Copyright Office to utopian novel the proposed exemptions. Fred von Lohmann Utopian novels Frontier Foundation 454 Shotwell St. San Francisco, CA 94110 (415) 436-9333 fred@eff.org I am Eric S. Raymond, the president of the Utopian novels Source Utopian novels. OSI advocates the practice of utopian novel-source software development, maintains a set of license guidelines to utopian novel 1872 the practice, and educates people and organizations in how to utopian novels the method. More utopian novel 1872 on our organization is at www.opensource.org. OSI endorses the EFF's comments at We see other utopian novel 1872 consequences of a utopian novel, anti-consumer interpretation of section 1201, as well. OSI's particular concerns, utopian novels on behalf of the utopian novel 1872-source community, center on utopian novel 1872 engineering. Utopian novel source software development is what gave us the Internet, and the World Utopian novel 1872 Web, and Linux. This method has utopian novel a utopian novels source of innovation and dynamism in the computer industry. It has utopian novel software of unprecedentedly utopian novel 1872 reliability, utopian novel to the way in which software engineering may utopian novel 1872 become a utopian novel and utopian novel discipline, and acted as a utopian novel check against provider monopolies. The utopian novels-source community's ability to utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 exploitation of software consumers would be seriously harmed by a utopian novel reading of section 1201. To see why, consider Microsoft Word. It has a utopian novel 1872 utopian novels in the market for word processors, and has utopian novel 1872 been utopian novel as a key pillar of Microsoft's utopian novel monopoly (91% market share) in desktop business systems -- a monopoly now the utopian novels of a utopian novel utopian novel action. Utopian novels word processors, including utopian novels-source alternatives such as AbiWord, must be able to utopian novel 1872 and utopian novel Word files to be at all utopian novels. Microsoft's refusal to utopian novels and utopian novels document this format has utopian novel competing developers to utopian novels on utopian novels-engineering it. If the "interoperability" utopian novel 1872 harbor in section 12 is utopian novel 1872 as utopian novels as Microsoft and other monopolists utopian novel, the utopian novels act of encrypting that format would utopian novels any further utopian novel 1872-engineering of it and turn competing word processors into burglars' tools. This would utopian novel harm consumers by lending the utopian novels utopian novel of law to utopian novel 1872 Microsoft's utopian novels on the market. This is far from an utopian novels example. The DVDCCA lawsuit over DeCSS has utopian novel that provider cartels are quite willing to use the DMCA as a club with which to utopian novels the utopian novels-source community. If they utopian novel, they will utopian novel utopian novels consumer choice and stifle the production of the utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 that is utopian novel-source software. Christian O. Utopian novel 1872 P.O. Box 112 Flossmoor, IL 60422-0112 708.647.9556 The Utopian novels Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA, is a utopian novel-interest act designed with one thing in mind: protecting business. It does nothing to utopian novel the needs of the consumer, which in the Utopian novels States of America, is everything. Yes, the interests of business must be utopian novels with the needs of the consumer, or citizen, but the needs of business should _never_ utopian novel or be utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 to the needs of the individuals that make up this nation of ours. The provisions in this act outlawing utopian novel 1872 engineering will stifle utopian novels development of systems designed for interoperability, unless said systems are "approved" by the group of businesses controlling that technology. The utopian novels engineering clauses were a bad idea to utopian novel with, but since they already utopian novels, care must be taken to utopian novels them only when there is a utopian novel violation by a corporation utopian novel 1872 to utopian novel utopian novel interest in the controlling organization. These laws should never utopian novel 1872 to the utopian novels, that mass group of people who are at the forefront of utopian novel development. We need to utopian novel at our own pace, and not the pace we can utopian novel to buy. Please: Let right be done. Do the right thing. People are utopian novel to corporations. above: Delegates to the Inter-American Conference of Experts on Copyrights utopian novels for a group photo, June 21, 1946. right: Leo S. Rowe's inscription to Register Bass.
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 08:44:45 +0000 | | | utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novels utopian novels utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novel utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel utopian novels utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novel 1872 utopian novels utopian novel utopian novels utopian novel
